Erwird Schreien, the great pre-existentialist German Philosopher, is purported to have said:
"Optimism in the face of certainty and certain disappointment is
the necessary refuge of
Illusionists, the Newly Married, Parents and the Old."
Illusionists, the Newly Married, Parents and the Old."
Optimism? Is it a form of delusional thinking? When your 70 year old Gastroenterologist tells her 70 year old patient -- lying prone and loopily just waking up from a twilight-sleep after a so-called scoping procedure (right! just a procedure):
"I'll see you in 12 years,"
what pray-tell should the patient's response be? How 'bout?
"Twelve years?
Are you totally daft?
TWELVE YEARS!
YOU'LL BE DEAD AND
I'LL BE BEING PUSHED IN BY A DISINTERESTED ATTENDANT!
TWELVE YEARS, MY VIOLATED ASS!"
For the record, I haven't had a colonoscopy in a number of years, now, I like my GI lady, and it's a total mystery to me how it is that this bit of questionable medical optimism woke with me, this morning. Kurt Eissler, a great post-existentialist Philosopher and Psychiatrist, made it a habit -- that is, before HE died -- of giving his dying patients subscriptions to magazines. I can imagine Kurt, now, sitting up in Heaven and reading old issues of Smithsonian Magazine from a subscription that expired not long after he did! BTW ... I don't think for him it was a matter of "That'll keep'em busy" but rather his belief that optimism is a good thing ... And I agree ... with apologies to my Gastroenterologist, if she's reading this, that is.
What's my point? When a friend tells you that there's nothing to live for, no reason to go on, or that the everyday pain of life is 'just too much,' what is it that they're saying? I'm not big on making recommendations and I am, right now, planning on going back to see my GI Doc in another 7 years or so, but I dare to recommend that when your friend makes one of those comments, it may well be ill-advised to take it as a testament to the value they put in your friendship.
Please, don't misunderstand me. A friend who draws you emotionally near by telling you that they're sad and struggling and could use the warmth of your hand in theirs is sharing with you that not trivial fraction of life that deals with loss and everyday disappointments that are expressed with a bonding feeling of sadness. And a bonding/proximating experience it is to share the wistful in life! But depression, as I keep repeating (some will say: "hey, the guy needs to convince himself" -- well, may ... be?), is in many ways the opposite of sadness. The depressed person pushes you away ... withdraws into sullenness ... the sad person wants you close.
To get specific ... The pessimistic person pays little attention to the fact that today is the last Day of Channukah when some fraction of 1 in 500 people worldwide celebrate that a small minority can survive even if they're not exactly like the other 499 of 500.
The pessimistic person, similarly, pays little attention to the fact that tomorrow is the day when, perhaps, 125 out of every 500 people worldwide celebrate the birth of a child. Now, how nifty is that! As we people-folk tend to take things personally, you can bet that maybe a majority of Christian kids see that day as a day when their parents celebrate them ... maybe not their little brother or sister ... but a day to celebrate them! And the gifts that some people pooh-pooh (as in Winnie the Pooh-pooh?), be assured! those kids see those gifts as proof that the holy-day is, at least in part, about how pleased their parents are that they were born.
So
Happy Channukah to all, ye Jewish Oldsters
and
Be Merry, My Old Christian Friends.
Shhhhh! Now to those of you who are not religiously-minded and find no solace in temporal optimism offered by such holidays, I give you a bit of compensatory doggerel written in (what today is a rainy) Philadelphia, 20 years ago.
‘Tis the Week in the Delaware Valley
On Dancer! On Prancer! Get going sweet Vixen!
There’s a party Thursday night on Lake Nockamixon.
Friday, stead of work we’ll have us a brew
While dining in Center City,
Chateaubriand for Two?
Saturday lunch on Ninth Street?
The gang’s ordering Christmas Stromboli
Sambuca, Linguini, maybe Cannoli.
Hey?
Does Tel Erhardt still have that place near Paoli?
Sunday? Philly’s partying for Monday nearly done
Rum Nogs, Hot Toddies, maybe a scone
As we sit by the fire and drink, just us! alone!
Loosen our belts ... Oh moan! Oh groan!
Tuesday? King of Prussia and Oxford Valley, too?
One more drink for me, a pudding for you!
Ah! Wednesday we’ll wrap, pick at Russell Stover
To wake Thursday morning ...
That’s Christmas Day ...
Both hung- and hanging-over!
The moral of my story could be no more clear:
If it’s weight gain and headache this week that you fear
As you don and don’t doff Christmas pounds year after year.
When invitations arrive ... comely, inviting and luminous
Send “regrets only” and tell your friends
Sorry ... I’ve joined the Ethical Freethinkers' Society and
ho-hum! ...
Become ....
A secular humanist.